Jump to content
Julian

Panasonic G6 vs GH2 video test!

Recommended Posts

 

Panasonic GH2 hacked

Moon Trial 5 hack, shot in 1080p HBR mode 25 fps (~ 60Mbps)

Standard profile -2-2-2-2

Panasonic 14-42mm kitlens, OIS on.

 

Looks like there are some dropped frames in the GH2 footage, did use a Sandisk 95MB/s card though...

 

Panasonic G6

AVCHD 1080p 25 fps (24Mbps)

Standard profile -5-5-5-5

Panasonic 14-42mm kitlens, OIS on.

 

Everything shot with the same fixed white balance at 1/50s, various apertures but same on both camera's at all times.

 

My first impressions:

The G6 looks better to me. Better shadow detail and a bit more detail in the highlights. Probably due to flatter picture.

 

The G6 shares the picture styles with the GH3, so no smooth like on the GH2.  Kept both camera's on standard to keep it as close as possible. Everything dialed down maximum.

 

Less noise at high iso's, less banding. Couldn't detect any moire.

 

Looks a tad less sharp than (hacked) GH2, but that could be up to the sharpening at -5. With some sharpening probably same detail level.

 

Rolling shutter looks the same to me.

 

Although the G6 is a bit smaller I actually prefer the grip to the GH2. It holds very nicely. The lcd is much much better. The color cast on the GH2 screen is horrible. The G6 looks pretty natural and true to the output. Funny thing: the viewfinder looks quite smaller to me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
EOSHD Pro Color for Sony cameras EOSHD Pro LOG for Sony CamerasEOSHD C-LOG and Film Profiles for All Canon DSLRs

I shot hacked with Moon Trial 5 at HBR (60Mbps). Might do more tests later. But it already looks pretty good for the G6 I think, so if I don't have to 'unhack' my GH2 I might keep it this way. On the other hand, I should try some more/other hacks.. so If I find the time :)

 

I'm planning on making some screendumbs so you can see the actual quality, the youtube compression is pretty harsh. Don't have time now, but here are some examples (make sure you see the full res 1080p image).

 

G6 on top, GH2 below. ISO 3200 and 160.

No tripod, so not a perfect test.

 

gallery_20742_44_918446.png

 

gallery_20742_44_1583485.png

 

gallery_20742_44_1920875.png

 

gallery_20742_44_1703638.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Video wont play for me but the G6 images look better to my eye. less noise in the mids in the top pic.

 

You should try against the intravenous II hack, that is the highest quality of the hack settings I've tried so far.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Is it relatively safe hacking a GH2? I have never really heard of anyone having any trouble, and people seem to swap hacks pretty easily.. Unlike Magic Lantern which I'v heard and even seen errors/camera lockups (even when a CF wasn't in with ML) and that was the "stable" version.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Video wont play for me but the G6 images look better to my eye. less noise in the mids in the top pic.

 

You should try against the intravenous II hack, that is the highest quality of the hack settings I've tried so far.

 

The ISO3200 example is sorta academic, to me.  I'd rather see more realistic comparisons at something like 640/800 where too much above that you're pretty much in a horrible lighting situation and just hoping you get an image you can use and then it becomes a contest of "which camera would I rather have when I'm not lighting anything and my light is shit?", more or less.

 

Some differences between the ISO160 examples could also come from the Standard profile reportedly not giving a correct exposure for medium gray on the GH2.  According to Shian Storm (ColorGHear) and his tests with scopes and handheld light meter (unconfirmed yet myself) only Nostalgia measures medium gray exposure @ 50% and the others are closer to 40%.  Perhaps they fixed this anomaly in the G6?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I cant get the video to play.

 

Anyhow i currently have a GH2 (hacked), and am thinking of moving to the G6.

I have been waiting for more video samples and comparisons to be posted before deciding, as i mostly use the camera for video. 

 

I must say based on the photos posted here I feel the GH2 is better. The GH2 is much sharper, a little more noisy, but i can filter most of that out in post.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is great news. It appears that the G6 possibly performs even better than the GH2! (contrary to what earlier videos showed).

I took both cityscape screenshots and put them together for detail comparison. I sharpened the G6 one a tiny little bit to match the GH2 (which brought up a little artifacting), as well as touching levels a little.

 

GH2 on the left, G6 on the right.


Hope is back.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have high hopes for this camera too.  I can't wait to dump my GH2s.  Hacks are only good for the most extreme detail.  But in reality, there's way less banding and better noise with the G6.  And I hope I won't have to use the most expensive Sandisk cards and I can go back to using 32GB cards. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have high hopes for this camera too.  I can't wait to dump my GH2s.  Hacks are only good for the most extreme detail.  But in reality, there's way less banding and better noise with the G6.  And I hope I won't have to use the most expensive Sandisk cards and I can go back to using 32GB cards. 


I shot a music video for Cabezones last monday using my beloved Sedna and the footage looks awesome. I love that detail and fine grain. But yeah, banding on the shadows and using high ISOs sometimes gets in the way, and on many shoots the stock codec quality will be more than enough, and the improvements the G6 brings to the table are great.

On the other hand, just think about the possibility of new hacks for the G6...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't have a monitor or a hdmi cable to attach it to my tv so can't test that.. Is that fixed in the GH3? might be fixed in the G6 too in that case.

 

I'm really impressed by the G6, especially for the price. Think I'll replace my GH2 for it and keep it next to my upcoming BMPCC if I don't want to bother with the huge files from the Pocket cam :)  1080p50/1080p60 also is a big plus imo. Going to play with that soon!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I didn't download any of the older G6 videos that were first online to check this, but could it be that their softness came from shooting at 1080p50/60? Perhaps the implementation of that new frame rate at that resolution on this same GH2 sensor isn't as good as 24p, and that's the mode in which those videos were shot? Did you try this, Julian?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Similar Content

    • By zoombeam
      The original SLR 12mm for micro four thirds.  Built in hood.  Mint.  Box is intact.  Comes with original caps and hood.  $300.00+ shipping.
    • By Ingerson
      Well, it’s been 8 months since I completed this and almost a year since I promised @mercer to post it once completed

      I don’t really know what to say about this, it’s my first short and I wanted to try this medium after trying music, photography, drawing/painting and all sorts of writing in order to figure out myself and my depression.

      It took me months to complete due to my mental state and lack of energy and I intended to post this sooner, but life can be a little too much sometimes. Or very often in my case.

      Even though it was the hardest creative thing I’ve done in my life, (despite having a background or experience in most of the separate artforms that make up a film) I was really lost in the entire process and I developed love/hate relationship to it. I wanted to quit all the time when I wrote it, when prepping, when shooting and during the long, motivational drainage that is editing.

      But I guess that’s also where the love was born. No matter all the mistakes I made, I could somehow save it and make a decent first short thanks to the editing by re-arranging the pieces I had. Throw away most of it, stretching what was left of it, slowing or speeding up some of it, playing some of it in reverse. Dubbing in new sound (needed, cause most of it was unusable. Note to self: Don’t forget sound!

      I’ve tried to make another short since, but haven’t completed the shoot. I don’t know if I’ll finish that one, it’s just a silly comedy I made with my then girlfriend, now fiancée on my phone (This one was shot on the DVX200 before anyone asks, cameras are important on this forum apperantly, hehe) because she wanted me to make something less depressing, but I guess I’m just a gloomy guy, all my new ideas are based on my different malfunctions.

      Hopefully I’ll work up enough energy to make another, I really want to.

      Anyway, enough talking. I hope you’ll give this a go and give me some pointers, but go easy on me, okay?

      Now, pick you poison:
       
      https://vimeo.com/272702923
       
      https://youtu.be/rsXdjH4I5YA

       

    • By Thecryptolounge
      Rarely used this bad boy, mainly bought it for my wedding a couple years back. Other than that it’s in great condition. Will sell it with the battery and the 32GB SD.
      Askig: $700






    • By Martin Facci
      Selling Panasonic GH5s
      It's almost new. 
      Only used on a few works as a B Camera. Really well taken care off.
      It includes original box, manuals and everything that comes with it.
      The price also includes.
      - Tilta Cage with baseplate and top handle
      - 3x Battery
      - 2x Charger
      - 2x DC-Coupler D-TAP
      Retail New Price 2700€ / OBO
      Selling Price 1900€ / OBO
      Ships from Spain, preferly to Europe but could send Worldwide if sellers pays the free
      Pics here:
      https://imgur.com/a/nUtmJZV
      More info or photos to
      [email protected]






    • By thebrothersthre3
      $430 + $10 shipping

      Make me an offer
      Selling my Panasonic GX85.

      Perfect condition. I've had it for a year. Used it to film a wedding, a party, and home video throughout the year (camping, birthdays).
      Comes with a Lens Turbo II speedbooster, Nikon mount. This gives you a wider field of view closer to full frame.
      Also comes with #3 batteries and a dual charger.
       
      Anyone who shoots Panasonic knows their cameras have very high image quality. 4k as well as HD up to 60fps. Also has very good IBIS, great to use with manual lenses. 

       







×
×
  • Create New...