Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
WideEyedPictures

Set Me Straight: Math For GH4 Crop Factor & Lenses

Recommended Posts

...and a Speedbooster!

 

I'm trying to wrap my head around what the mathematical formula must be to gauge how wide/zoomed lenses will be on a GH4 with a Speedbooster. What I know so far:

 

- Shooting 4K, the crop is 2.3

- Shooting 1080, crop is 2.0

- Metabones Speed Booster lessens crop by 0.71

- Generic Speed Boosters lessen crop by 0.72

 

Is the math: " FF LENS x CROP x BOOSTER ="?

 

or for a 18mm lens:

 

18mm [Lens] x 2.3 [4K Crop] x 0.72 [Metabones] = A 29.808mm lens equivalent?

 

To make matters more confusing to me, that only covers full frame lenses, so how do we determine the results on lenses for APS-C lenses? That I have NO idea on how the math may work.

 

Thanks so much!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
EOSHD Pro Color for Sony cameras EOSHD Pro LOG for Sony CamerasEOSHD C-LOG and Film Profiles for All Canon DSLRs

Is that so?

 

As I understood it, APS-C lenses actually direct the light into a more narrow area. This is why an APS-C lens on a full frame camera shows so much vignetting.

 

Thus, if the amount of area the APS-C lens's light is producing, that seems like it's helping to decrease the crop factor some by putting more of the entire lenses image onto the sensor than that of a full frame lens.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Focal lengths are focal lengths. The sensor size they cover is independent of that.

 

EDIT: To be clear - always calculate based on the focal length. To base FoV equivalent calculation on the projected image circle is like saying a pound of feathers is lighter than a pound of iron.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As I understood it, APS-C lenses actually direct the light into a more narrow area. This is why an APS-C lens on a full frame camera shows so much vignetting.

 

This part is right. To get the APS-C lens fill the full frame sensor, you'd need a focal expander, the opposite of a Speedbooster, with loss of light.

 

 

Thus, if the amount of area the APS-C lens's light is producing, that seems like it's helping to decrease the crop factor some by putting more of the entire lenses image onto the sensor than that of a full frame lens.

 

I see your point. You say a pound of iron will slay your neighbour beneath your window, but the feathers won't. You mean, a 50mm f 2.0 that's calculated for full frame will appear darker on APS-C than a 50mm f2.0 that's calculated for APS-C? 

 

No, because these values are invariable, only the FoV changes (not because of the lens, but because of the sensor size, the APS-C lens just might have a vignette). 

 

It's more puzzling with a focal reducer. The FoV changes, the amount of light changes, but actually the DoF doesn't change. But then again it does, because you always think about DoF in conjunction with FoV. With narrowFoV you could always have shallowDoF.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I may have fallen victim to the mistake several others have made. I certainly understand the difference between focal length and field of view. I said the former but meant the latter.

So my curiosity lays in what the field of view equivalent is of a normal lens when placed on the GH4 with not only it's 2.3x crop field of view inherent of that sensor, but the effect of the focal reducer which opens the crop up a bit more.

And my curiosity and confusion increase with lenses made specifically for APS-C lenses. I understand a lens like that will "see" just as far as any lens of the same resume but it's field of view is narrowed thus lessening the crop factor - I just don't know what math to do to figure that out.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The OP is asking a simple question. Why are you guys bringing all this complicated semantics into it?

 

To answer your question, your calculation is wrong.

It should be Lens focal length * Speedbooster * Crop factor.

 

So a 35mm lens * 0.71 speedbooster * 2x crop factor = 50mm (or 49.7mm to be exact). This basically means that a lens with a speedbooster attached to a Micro Four Thirds camera will become the same focal length as if the lens was just mounted on an APS-C camera.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Ebrahim Saadawi

To simplify,

GH4 in 4K: 2.3 crop factor.
GH4 in 4K with SB: 1.65x crop factor.

GH4 in 1080p: 2x crop factor
GH4 in 1080p with SB: 1.44x cropfactor

That's for full frame equivalence of course.

18mm ff lens on GH4 in 4K with SB: 18 x 1.65 = 29mm on full frame FOV

Don't think too much about it! :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The OP is asking a simple question. Why are you guys bringing all this complicated semantics into it?

 

To answer your question, your calculation is wrong.

It should be Lens focal length * Speedbooster * Crop factor.

 

 

To simplify,

GH4 in 4K: 2.3 crop factor.
GH4 in 4K with SB: 1.65x crop factor.

GH4 in 1080p: 2x crop factor
GH4 in 1080p with SB: 1.44x cropfactor

That's for full frame equivalence of course.

18mm ff lens on GH4 in 4K with SB: 18 x 1.65 = 29mm on full frame FOV

Don't think too much about it! :D

 

 

I appreciate your help (and defense) very much!

 

It would appear that the result is the same regardless of the order of multiplication (listen... I'm an artist who's not good at math - sorry!) Lens*Crop*SB is the same as Lens*SB*Crop

 

Either way, it looks like that makes total sense to me now. I know the formula and I can apply that for any future lenses I may check out.

 

But the last mystery remains - how to do this with an ASP-C lens who's FoV would be different on a MFT lens as opposed to a full frame equivalent. But I THINK I know how to figure this out and will report back.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I appreciate your help (and defense) very much!

 

It would appear that the result is the same regardless of the order of multiplication (listen... I'm an artist who's not good at math - sorry!) Lens*Crop*SB is the same as Lens*SB*Crop

 

Either way, it looks like that makes total sense to me now. I know the formula and I can apply that for any future lenses I may check out.

 

But the last mystery remains - how to do this with an ASP-C lens who's FoV would be different on a MFT lens as opposed to a full frame equivalent. But I THINK I know how to figure this out and will report back.

My bad :) When I did your formula the first time, I got a completely different result.

 

APS-C lenses (like Canon EF-S or Nikon DX) still use the standard focal length numbers. The only difference is that those lenses are not big enough to fill a full frame camera's sensor, hence the vignette/circle. This is also why you can use APS-C lenses on speed booster on MFT but you cant do the same on APS-C cameras like the Sony NEX.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

just don't worry about the math of APS-C lenses.  They are still fullframe lenses, but will have vignetting if placed on a fullframe camera.

 

Take for instace the Sigma 18-35 mm.  If the speedbooster takes the crop factor of the GH4, down past 1.5x or below you will have vignettting @ 18mm. keep it at 1.6 and above, and you're good.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ye gods I thought I was pretty clear. Focal lengths are focal lengths. Calculate your FoV crop based on the focal length of the lens. Doesn't matter what image circle it covers. That only affects whether or not you can actually use the lens, but not your math.

 

So just do this:

 

Focal Length * Crop Factor * Focal Reducer Factor

 

 

just don't worry about the math of APS-C lenses.  They are still fullframe lenses, but will have vignetting if placed on a fullframe camera.

Which means they are not full-frame lenses, because they project an image circle that does not cover an area of 36mm x 24mm.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So Canon send you a unit, purchases a lot of sponsored content on DPR to praise the video capabilities and now considers a major firmware to unlock this body ? The sales must be very bad. Seems to be little and too late for Canon.

In my case the 5d4 was the last drop of non sense from this company. I'm done, I bought a GH5. They would have to come up with more than band aid fix to convince me to drop another $3500. A bit of improvement on the crop and codec is not going to cut it. Does the mark 4 even have the hardware to fix all the issues ? Let's see what they announce at NAB.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Similar Content

    • By Nocturnes
      Looking for a quick sale, buyer pays to ship.
      The body literally has under 10 on the shutter and only pulled out to test. I, unfortunately, do not need the camera anymore, but it shoots extremely nice stills and is a good contender for video especially once the magic lantern hack comes out.
      Ready to ship or meet in San Diego area.
      $2700 for the camera with (2) Cf cards and an extra OEM Battery (Not pictured but will be in box)
      Venmo



    • By Nocturnes
      Hey, all, I have a basically brand new 5D Mark IV for sale that I got recently but no longer need. Took out to test and found it worked great, I just do not need it anymore at the moment.
      Comes with all original accessories and is ready to be registered for warranty if needed.
      Will also be including (2) 16GB CF cards and an additional canon battery if bought at asking price (not pictured)
      Will take $2700 Shipped to US Lower 48 (Additional cost if outside) - Paypal
      Located in San Diego, CA 



    • By pintowar
      I am selling a complete pack of Samsung NX1 that includes the following:
      -Body NX1 camera
      -Samsung NX 16-50mm f / 2.0-2.8 S Series Zoom OIS lens
      -Grip and 2 batteries
      -Charger

      Totally brand new. Sealed and with the plastic still put. As seen in the photos.

      Shipping to worldwide.
      Price: 2100 €, shipping costs included.
      Method of payment: by bank transfer or Paypal.



    • By Lintelfilm
      I imagine people here are going to be wary of buying considering certain recent events on the forum, but you can confirm my authenticity easily as my video company is well established online (just Google "Lintelfilm") and I'm happy to Skype etc if anyone has questions. I'd prefer to sell to UK but am open to offers from elsewhere, and preferably only to regular forum members. Postage not included but will be charged at cost. My name is Matt - I haven't hung out here for a while but older forum members will remember me (probably mainly from my various unnecessary spats with Mr Reid!). Andy Lee can confirm this I'm sure. Also, if I were to scam you, you could easily damage my business reputation online which really would be a serious problem for me and my family!
      This stuff will probably go on eBay by the end of the week so let me know asap if you're interested. All in good/great condition unless stated.
      FOR SALE (please DM me for prices):
      1: BMPCC with: Viewfactor Cage, Z-Finder, SmallRig top handle, external Sony NF-P battery plate (attached to top handle via my own design in the most elegant battery solution I've seen for the camera!), iRig Pre (modded for BMPCC). Pics below (looks like I didn't attach the battery to the plate properly - that slight angle is is not normal). Lens, Speed Booster and NP-F battery not included (lens & SB for sale separately, see below).

      2: BMPCC to Nikon Metabones Speed Booster. It works flawlessly and is in great condition. It arrived brand new with a very small, wafer thin chip on the very side of the glass that is not anywhere near the image circle. I considered returning it but as it functions perfectly it is just cosmetic and seemed pointless. It's not deep enough to be a danger to the glass and it hasn't changed since day 1. This is just for full disclosure. See chip at 2'O-clock on the image below. I'm a working pro not a gear fetishist so although all my stuff is in very good shape, well looked after and cosmetically still very nice, it has been used properly and not handled with kid gloves, so please don't expect "as new" condition - however I'll endeavour to point out anything that may be considered an issue regarding resale value etc.  

      3: GH4 with "unofficial" V-Log installed (which I don't recommend using anyway, official or not - not even in 10bit with an external recorder. It's a farce and a travesty by Panasonic). 
      4: MFT-Nikon 0.71x Metabones Speed Booster (works perfectly, glass is fine)
      5: SmallRig Cage (fits GH4 and many other DSLR-like cameras)
      6: Panasonic 12-35mm f/2.8
      7: Panasonic/Leica 25mm f/1.4
      8: Sigma 18-35mm 1.8 Nikon mount
      9: Tokina 11-16mm 2.8 DX (V1) Nikon mount
      10: Nikkor 105mm f/2.5 AI (best version of this wonderful manual lens, great condition)
      11: Nikkor 85mm f/2.0 AI-s - very slight stiffness at one end of focus action, but not prohibitive to getting focus. Otherwise great condition. 
      12: Sennheiser MKE400 with Sennheiser furry windshield (small shotgun mic with 3.5mm jack)
      13: Tiffen 77mm Vari-ND
      14: Hoya 77mm IR cut filter
      Again, please DM for prices of items you are interested in.
      Thanks
       
       
      I should say that I'm selling all this stuff because I recently switched to Canon. I'm loathe to sell the BMPCC because I LOVE the image and this is a great, very solid and very functional setup I've built for it that addresses almost all the functionality issues of the camera. But "business before pleasure" as they say and that's why I finally gave in to the Canon call. No one else does cameras you can just pick up and shoot with in any situation and be sure you'll grab solid images.
    • By bbhaltz
      Hi guys, I was just having a look on b&h at the ef to bmpcc speed boosters and found two different versions listed:
      http://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1064603-REG/metabones_mb_spef_bmpcc_bm1_canon_ef_to_bmpcc.html
      and
      http://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1174582-REG/metabones_mb_spef_bmpcc_bt1_metabones_canon_ef_lens.html
      I was just wondering if anyone knows what the 'T' in the second link means? Is it an updated version?
      Thanks.
×
×
  • Create New...