Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
QuickHitRecord

Iscorama VS Iscomorphot 8 2x VS Iscomorphot 8 1.5x

Recommended Posts

Since I have all three at the moment, I decided to make a test for my fellow anamorphic enthusiasts: 

 

http://vimeo.com/60401188

 

Not exactly scientific, but I tried to be methodical. The Iscorama is sharp wide open, but my Iscomorphot 2x has to be closed down to f/2.8 or smaller, and the Iscomorphot 1.5x really isn't too useful before f/5.6.

 

They each have their own unique character. Which image do you prefer?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
EOSHD Pro Color for Sony cameras EOSHD Pro LOG for Sony Cameras

The iscomorphot 2x wins for me.  I think its mainly due to the diopter allowing you to get slightly closer than the iscorama, yet thanks to the beast of a mod, you have got very close without the dipoter:)  Adding the dipoter boosts all the lovely nuances of the anamorphic bokeh distortion in the same way bokeh is more creamy with a longer lens at the same aperture.

 

I love the colours too.  I think what makes this test so superb is the interaction from your model.  It's nice to see how the lenses render a human face.  I felt the lower contrast and shallower dof thanks to the diopters, as well as the slightly softer image overally of the two 8mm's works really well in render the human face.  Please tell me your model is an actor?  She looks as if she needs to be in a french speaking 16mm anamorphic movie!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

very nice!

 

i liked them all at smaller apertures,... but then i've been getting sick of the super shallow depth of field look and i think they all, even the last looked much more cinematic when stopped down. the f8 shots are my favorite.

 

maybe its just the plethora of spherical shooters using shallow Dof that shallow Dof even anamorphic reminds me of regular video now. not criticizing Quickhitrecord in anyway, just my oddball brain.

 

but i was like " very nice, very nice too, very nice as well, this too is nice, whooaaaa!"

 

so is it just me or does f8 look more special than the larger apertures? perhaps the ratio of bokeh to clear + anamorphic bending ties it all together?

 

i will stop blabbering now  :P

 

thanks for the test, great job Quickhitrecord!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks, guys. I had fun doing this one.

 

I felt the lower contrast and shallower dof thanks to the diopters, as well as the slightly softer image overally of the two 8mm's works really well in render the human face.  Please tell me your model is an actor?  She looks as if she needs to be in a french speaking 16mm anamorphic movie!

 

I think that a big part of what many of us love about the "anamorphic look" is not from the lens, but from the diopters. They can be a challenge to work with but they do add a unique-looking bokeh that is not achievable by manipulating the aperture alone.

 

My model teaches photography for a living, so she's not afraid to be in front of a camera. I think that she's got a great face for cinema too. Maybe I'll see if I can write a short around a character that she could play.

 

What is your mod on the Iscorama 36?

 

It's Rich's amazing minimum focus mod. I can now focus wide open as close as 2'10" before the front element screws right off. It makes me nervous to do this so I usually limit myself to 3'6" or so. But still, it breathed new life into this lens for me.

 

so is it just me or does f8 look more special than the larger apertures? perhaps the ratio of bokeh to clear + anamorphic bending ties it all together?

 

I completely agree with you. Shallow DOF is overused and lately I haven't been using it as much. Actually, of everything that I shot here, I think that the Iscomorphot 8 1.5x at f/5.6 is my favorite look. Combined with FilmConvert, I'm getting a picture that I can't believe came out of a digital camera.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the comparison! Lovely images. The Iscorama wins for me. The Iscomorphot 8/2x is nice as well. I really have to get mine going but I think something is wrong with it.. Can't seem to get sharp images at big apertures, I'll make a topic about it soon.

 

I also like the F8 look. I think bigger apertures could still be useful with longer focus distances, to get a similar bokeh.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I love the fact that you can crop the Iscomorphot x2 & it still gives the Iscorama a run for its money!

I think if you'd left it uncropped it would've been the overall winner, especially at f5.6, which for me seems to be the optimum aperture.

I bought my x2 by mistake or should that be a drunken ebay moment a couple of xmas ago & there's something about it, almost like a special coating on the lenses (but most probably because 2 sets of doublets & no moving parts), that gives you that look.

 

Thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Great test! Really like the Isco and 2x. Very sharp.

 

Also, your spot on when it comes to the diopters. My two tokinas, add a nice bokeh and yes a bit of finagling. But, with a touch of color and a dab of film grain...well, I think we all know.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just received the Iscomorphot 8, could you tell me what clamp are you using with it ? Thank you

 

Here's how I am mounting mine: http://www.eoshd.com/comments/uploads/gallery/album_14/gallery_18451_14_27471.jpg

 

There are probably other ways to do it, but this is what I came up with to prevent the lens from twisting when I am focusing. Hope this helps and I can't wait to see your videos!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here's how I am mounting mine: http://www.eoshd.com/comments/uploads/gallery/album_14/gallery_18451_14_27471.jpg

 

There are probably other ways to do it, but this is what I came up with to prevent the lens from twisting when I am focusing. Hope this helps and I can't wait to see your videos!

Thank you :) I did a quick test with it this afternoon, but I have to bring it to a photograph repairer for the focus ring. At first glance this lens is less sharp than my baby Hypergonar, I have to put the prime lens at least on f/5.6, even for wide shot, when with the Hypergonar I can do wide shot at fast aperture (on the Iscomorphot 1.5 fast shot gives blurry / unsharp and color aberration. f/5.6 begin to be better, and especially with the Tokina diopter.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thank you :) I did a quick test with it this afternoon, but I have to bring it to a photograph repairer for the focus ring. At first glance this lens is less sharp than my baby Hypergonar, I have to put the prime lens at least on f/5.6, even for wide shot, when with the Hypergonar I can do wide shot at fast aperture (on the Iscomorphot 1.5 fast shot gives blurry / unsharp and color aberration. f/5.6 begin to be better, and especially with the Tokina diopter.

 

Yes, mine is quite unusable before f/5.6. But once you put it there, it gives an unbelievable image (in my opinion). And it is rack-focusable (and focuses as close as 0.5m), which makes it the easiest, most user-friendly anamorphic that I have ever owned.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How does your baby ISCO differ from the other design like this one in terms of performance etc ,,,

 

 

$(KGrHqV,!pMFENLj7BZyBRK9y6(M(!~~60_57.J

Yes, mine is quite unusable before f/5.6. But once you put it there, it gives an unbelievable image (in my opinion). And it is rack-focusable (and focuses as close as 0.5m), which makes it the easiest, most user-friendly anamorphic that I have ever owned.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here's how I am mounting mine: http://www.eoshd.com/comments/uploads/gallery/album_14/gallery_18451_14_27471.jpg

 

There are probably other ways to do it, but this is what I came up with to prevent the lens from twisting when I am focusing. Hope this helps and I can't wait to see your videos!

 

Redstan clamp for bolex moller can also be used with the iscomorphot 8 1.5x

 

iscomorphot.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How does your baby ISCO differ from the other design like this one in terms of performance etc ,,,

 

I had one of those once: http://www.eoshd.com/comments/topic/741-isco-gottingen-anamorphot-15x-not-to-be-confused-with-iscormorphot-15x

 

That was a focus-through design and very difficult to work with. You have to reposition the camera to focus. The Iscomorphot 8 1.5x is very easy to use (fully rack-focusable and has a minimum focus distance of about 2.5'), as long as you keep your aperture above f/5.6.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Similar Content

    • By redimp
      Things are on ebay, but I can take them off and offer discounted prices.
      Paypal only, free shipping to paypal address. Bundles isco+rangefidner, or angie+isco+rangefidner, bmmcc+monitor or all of items together will go for discounted prices, and I will include freebies like batteries for camera and monitor, charger, clamps for isco and rangefidner, rig for camera, follow focus and a free tripod. All of budget but decent quality.
      isco http://www.ebay.com/itm/RARE-Iscorama-Set-ISCO-S8-2x-Animex-Anamorphic-Lens-Attachment-single-focus/232483641842
      rangefidner http://www.ebay.com/itm/SLR-Magic-Rangefinder-single-focus-solution-for-anamorphic-lenses-basic-version/232483615371
      bmmcc http://www.ebay.com/itm/Blackmagic-Design-Micro-Cinema-Camera-Body-Only-CINECAMMICHDMFT/232483678200
      monitor (has some desqueeze for anamorphic) http://www.ebay.com/itm/Neway-7-HDMI-field-monitor-with-manual-anamorphic-desqueeze/232483687880
      angenieux (black clone, MIJ) http://www.ebay.com/itm/Angenieux-25mm-f-0-95-C-Mount-Lens/232483693338
      Best,
      Max.
    • By Rick Moonbeam Darge
      Selling my Iscorama Pre-36 beauty with the original taking lens! I bought this for a feature film back in 2014 and paid way more than my asking price. Used only indoors for 7 solid days. Upon completion the lens went back into the pelican where it was stored in my studio for the past 3 years. I've held onto it for sentimentality and because it's gorgeous but now it's time to say goodbye. No scratches. Very clean glass. No fungus. The usual internal dust inside the elements as one would expect from a lens that's from the late 1960s. Some mild oxidation on the physical barrel that bars no effect on image quality.
      I really love this lens and I'm sad to see it go but hopefully it will find a better home with more usage. I'm located in Los Angeles, California but will ship worldwide upon payment. 
       
      ASKING $4,250 
            
       
      Also included in this sale; 
      • SLR Magic 77 MC Achromatic Diopter +0.33
      • SLR Magic 77 MC Achromatic Diopter +1.3 
      • (3) 72mm FUJIMI CLOSE FILTERS - +1, +2, +4 
      • Pelican 1200 Carrying Case 
      ALL ITEMS
      CU FILTERS
      FRONT ELEMENT
      INSIDE CASE
      PELICAN CASE
      SIDE VIEW
      SIDE VIEW_2
       
    • By Hunterj11
      See my last post on the Isco 54 to read my offensive pre-amble to these lens sales.  Kisses
      Ebay auction ends in 24hrs.  Link at bottom of post.
      Super expensive over priced mint condition Iscorama pre 36 Cinegon Anamorphic Lens with redstan clamp and custom made dog schidt optics pl mount 58mm spherical taking lens.  Absolute mint condition.  You'll never see this again because nothing like it exists on this plane of existence.  Yes it's way overpriced and you can't afford it so don't buy it because I'm an idiot for even thinking of selling the jewel of the Nile.  Set for 24hr auction cause I'm desperate for fast cash.  Likely to greedily out it back in my safe tomorrow morning once no one bids on it because I'm so so stupid for trying to sell it.  If you are drooling and have ridiculous sums of disposable money then make my nightmare a reality and buy my most favorite beautiful precious lens I've ever owned.  This thing is so nice.  If you have the cash it's impossible for you to be anything but head over heals in love with it at first sight.  Good luck.  Damn you.
       
      https://www.ebay.com/itm/182609548983 



    • By Hunterj11
      Link to auction at bottom of post.  If you want to tell me about how this is overpriced and blah blah blah save it and don't message me with your sad whiny comments.  Sorry to roll in hot here but every time I let the anamorphic community know I'm selling a super rare expensive item I get bombarded by a bunch of little cry baby failures who can't afford to buy precision high end gear and so they post complaints about the pricing or the injustice of me selling amazing gear that they can't afford because they are smug little losers without money living in their parents basement obsessively refreshing message board pages just waiting to spew forth their venomous vitriol thinly masking their self hatred and depression regarding the pathetic state of their sad boring failure of a life.  Save your stupid selfish thoughts for your Mommy cause she's the only one who cares to listen to Mommy's special angel. 
       
      Ok now that that's over with....I'm selling the nicest damn iscorama 54 lens you'll ever see ever.   24hr auction.  Act fast.  Here are the details kiddos:
      You'll never ever see an iscorama 54 MC in this good of condition. It is flawless mint condition. 
      I'm putting this up for 1 day only. Bidding starts at 6k. Some will tell me that that's too expensive. I'm of the opinion that it's worth at least 7500$ in this type of shape. How this lens is in practically brand new condition being somewhere in the order of 50 years old is perplexing. This should be in a museum. 
       
      This auction is for one day. If it doesn't sell I might put it back on the shelf and keep it....not sure honestly what I'll do if it doesn't sell by tomorrow morning. I'm already regretting doing this but I need to raise 20k asap for a non gear related issue so I'm in lunatic liquidation mode.
       
      I can't stress this enough....this thing is a work of art. So beautiful.
       
      On top of that I have a ridiculously rare iscorama pre 36 cinegon version that is also in mint condition and paired with a custom "Richard Gale Optics" 58mm Arri PL mount taking lens specifically engineered for the iscorama cinegon. It's equally a work of art so if you are interested in that as well check out my auction page.
       
      Comes with a redstan clamp and follow Focus gear. Original box included as well. No Caps unfortunately but I assure you I'll find some other roughly fitting Caps to put on to protect the glass during shipping.
       
      Good luck and bring your checkbooks to the party. Lets do this.
      https://www.ebay.com/itm/182609506564 

    • By hotdog
      Title says it all. Looking for a good copy of the pre36 or 36. I think it's time for me to move on from my 16D.
×