Jump to content

Google Pixel XL Camera Sample 4K - The Best Yet?


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 54
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

They'll have to pry it from my dead hands.  Which may happen soon enough.

Have you seen how many YT views explosive Note7s get?  I bet an explosive Note7 on an Edlkrone slide would raise enough money for 2 Pixels ;).  P.S. If Samsung hadn't fucked up (or I didn't

Google worked closely with Qualcomm on the pixel. The EIS uses the gyroscopes to adjust for shake.  It is supposed to be very good indeed and is said to be free of the artifacts that are common in oth

Posted Images

3 hours ago, Don Kotlos said:

I don't know if you are joking, but that could definitely explain the amazing quality!

In any case, in a couple of weeks I will know...

Not joking, I went looking for the video after it disappeared. I didn't see what the OP posted, but this one has come up as the Cinematic Pixel fake, and the poster supposedly did the same thing with the iPhone for the clickbait.

https://9to5google.com/2016/10/09/check-out-this-stunning-4k-footage-taken-with-the-pixel-xl-video/

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

"As for Google's touted video stabilization? It definitely works. I didn't have any extreme circumstances under which to test it, but for just holding your phone and walking around shooting video, it makes a huge difference. I mean, I doubt you'd think I was using a gimbal, but it's still very smooth."

"Finally, let's talk about the electronic image stabilization. It works! I have a video sample, shot in 4K, below, to demonstrate it. It does give video a slightly jarring panning effect if you're too subtle with your movement, but overall? For something shot with one hand over my head, this is incredibly smooth."

http://www.androidpolice.com/2016/10/18/google-pixel-review-a-very-good-phone-by-google/

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

There are quite few reviews out there, but non of them offered extensive review of the video. 

Stabilization looks alright, but interestingly it looks like pixel has HDR video during non-stabilized videos. Look at the much lower noise during the non-stabilized video on the left:

Here is a comparison between iphone 7, pixel, S7:

Maybe a bit sharper than what I like, but colors are better than the S7 so I am happy. 

Unfortunately while still among the top smartphone cameras, it is nothing close to what that youtube scammer had posted :) 

Link to post
Share on other sites

You guys seen this one? :grimace:

Quote

EKTRA_Phone_Main_2x.png

ManualMode_wOptions.png

Shoot in 4K video. Experiment with classic Kodak film grains, vignettes and Super 8 filters.

Experience the Kodak clarity, precision and detail that the world's leading filmmakers and photographers have always trusted.

~ http://www.kodak.com/consumer/products/ektra/default.htm

Yeah. Hum. Not sure. Kodak used to be a household name, now it might just be a gimmick? We'll have to see about that.

Meanwhile Xiaomi is at it again! Note 2 http://www.mi.com/minote2/ and concept (but real and soon availlable??) MIX: http://www.mi.com/mix/ . That's kind of exciting, no?

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 10/19/2016 at 2:08 PM, Don Kotlos said:

There are quite few reviews out there, but non of them offered extensive review of the video. 

Stabilization looks alright, but interestingly it looks like pixel has HDR video during non-stabilized videos. Look at the much lower noise during the non-stabilized video on the left

Here is a comparison between iphone 7, pixel,

Maybe a bit sharper than what I like, but colors are better than the S7 so I am happy. 

Unfortunately while still among the top smartphone cameras, it is nothing close to what that youtube scammer had posted :) 

The only usable one here is the S7.  If you look at the lines on the brick wall, it has the least amount of the micro rolling shutter and has no distracting micro motion blur for a split second that's an artifact from digital stabilization.  You can put warp stabilizer on the S7 footage and achieve some amazing results where the other 2, you can't correct micro motion blur or micro rolling shutter.

Overall, the image quality of all these phones are still pretty terrible.  But with some other apps, maybe you can achieve better results.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I wholeheartedly agree. There's a couple of things. Dynamic range, depth of field (and sharpness harshness front to back) , and codec/bitrate which really give it a smartphone look. That's the areas they really need to improve in! The Cinema4K app helps a little here.

Think it's a little gimmicky to say 'I shot this whole thing on just a smartphone'. Well, what was the reason behind it? 'Well, uh, it makes it instantly more impressive, no?'. Yeah, not sure it works that way. And it might be decent or good. But wouldn't it have turned out better with some more production behind it? And the things that are shot, weren't shot with 'just a smartphone'. Didn't they have like quite elaborate set-ups for it? I don't know. I don't think I'll be shooting anything meaningful on a smartphone any day soon. I'll still go for that dedicated camera option.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Here are my thoughts after playing with the Pixel that I received just yesterday. 

As many have already said, quality is very similar with most top end phones. It is not a replacement for a large sensor camera, it is just useful to have when the large sensor camera is not with you (c'mon you all know that happens :) ).  Add some skill, and you can get some useful footage out of any of these phones, that you would otherwise not have at all. Shoot a movie? Fuck no. 

I am not convinced by EIS yet. EIS artifacts seem worse in low light. It might have to do with the shutter speed I am not sure yet.  Not that OIS is much better. If you want stabilization then you are better off with that $300 Osmo mobile gimbal. I mean miles better. But really who is going to carry that osmo thingy around? 

Colors are better on the Pixel than the S7. In video makes more of a difference. 

Bad flares. You can also notice them on the sample videos posted in this thread. 

I would say photos are better on the Pixel as well, but Samsung has the best camera app. I doubt the average phone user would notice, but if you take photography seriously and you want to have full manual control then you are better off with the S7. Or download another app ;) .  

As a side note: I wasn't planning on using google assistant, but damn this thing just works. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


×
×
  • Create New...