Close Menu
    EOSHD Shooter’s Guides
    • New EOSHD Pro Color 5 is out now, for all Sony mirrorless cameras including the A7S III!
    • EOSHD C-LOG and Film Simulation Picture Profiles for Canon
    X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
    X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
    EOSHD.com – Filmmaking Gear and Camera Reviews
    STORE
    • Forum
    • YouTube
    • Instagram
    • 𝕏
    • PRO COLOR 5
    • EOSHD C-LOG
    • Store
      • The EOSHD 5D Mark III 3.5K RAW Shooter’s Guide
      • The EOSHD 50D Raw Shooter’s Guide
      • The EOSHD Anamorphic Shooter’s Guide 2nd Edition
      • The EOSHD Sony A7 Series Shooter’s Guide to Full Frame Lenses
      • The EOSHD Panasonic GH4 Shooter’s Guide
      • The EOSHD Panasonic GH3 Shooter’s Guide
      • The EOSHD Panasonic GH2 Shooter’s Guide
      • The EOSHD Sony A7R II Setup Guide
      • The EOSHD Samsung NX1 Setup Guide
    • Cart
    • Contact
    • More
      • EOSHD Reviews
      • EOSHD Cinematography
      • About EOSHD / Andrew Reid
      • Blog RSS Feed
      • Facebook
    EOSHD.com – Filmmaking Gear and Camera Reviews
    You are at:Home » Is 48p evil?

    Is 48p evil?

    Andrew Reid (EOSHD)By Andrew Reid (EOSHD)April 12, 2011 News 3 Mins Read

    At the moment cinema purists around the world are getting out of their beds on the wrong side. Two prominent filmmakers are attempting to squash the gold standard of cinema and home displays are taking all sorts of unpleasant turns with high frame rates and 3D helping to shift sets in the way that high megapixels help the unwashed masses buy cameras.

    2D projection and shooting, along with 24fps has been the stable cinema format for 90 years, and it works very well.

    Early attempts at 3D have been mostly shocking and hard on the eyes, even Avatar gave me a headache.

    Peter Jackson and James Cameron are taking moves to solve the issues one by one. First the weight and complexity of the cameras is being dramatically reduced. Cameron revealed at NAB 2011 that he was behind almost every shot on Avatar himself, hands on with the camera and only the steadicam shots were by an operator. Great stuff!

    Secondly the cameras and projection technology is being pushed onwards. They still have some way to go before we lose the glasses and convergence point issue which causes eye strain but for The Hobbit Peter Jackson is going to get rid of 24p, since he blames it for a distracting stuttering effect see his blog post here.

    In 2D this effect looks cinematic and unworldly – the opposite of reality TV or TV news but in 3D it’s just distracting. I agree.

    Peter Jackson isn’t blind, if he says 24p doesn’t work for 3D then he must be onto something. So The Hobbit will be shot in 48p, double the frame rate of normal cinema and the purists are unhappy. I am going to wait to see it projected in a cinema before I judge what could be the new Hollywood standard of cinema shooting and projection.

    Of course ‘cinematic’ is more than a frame rate – it is the way the camera draws attention with depth of field and focus, it is a whole number of other things. Dynamic range, framing, sound.

    I don’t blame 48p or 60p.

    I blame the way people are digesting films and video in the home. Modern displays are awful.

    Footage looks like ‘digital sick’ to quote Sam Morgan Moore because we are watching it on digital displays which are extremely clinical and technically revealing.

    I have spent a lot of time on low-fi lenses for DSLRs because you get a more cinematic look like that and you get the life put back into the image.

    It’s the same with displays. An LED backlit TFT monitor is not going to look cinematic, whether your footage is shot at 24p or 60p. Plasma displays are better but the most critical technology for that ‘cinematic look’ is the projector.

    It’s key to it’s all – that beam of light casting light and shadows onto a silver screen.

    When you view DSLR footage through high end projection systems all the flaws that we see up close on a computer screen disappear.

    So don’t blame the camera, or even the frame rate. Get a projector!

    24p 48p peter jackson The Hobbit
    Andrew Reid (EOSHD)
    • Website

    British filmmaker and editor of EOSHD. On this blog I share my creative and technical knowledge as I shoot.

    Related Posts

    Camera prices – Have the Japanese taken leave of their senses?

    Read More

    What to expect from Nikon’s first RED mirrorless camera, the Nikon Zr

    Read More

    The Panasonic S1 II pricing is wrong – so is the entire product strategy

    Read More

    EOSHD Pro Color 5 for All Sony cameras

    EOSHD C-LOG and Film Profiles for All Canon DSLRs

    EOSHD Z-LOG for Nikon cameras

    Articles by category
    • Anamorphic
    • Featured
    • Filmmaking
    • Interview
    • Lens
    • News
    • Opinion
    • RAW Video
    • Reviews
    • Rumors
    • Satire/Opinion
    • Shooter's Guides / LUTs / Colour Profiles
    • YouTube
    Blog post archives
    • Instagram
    • Twitter
    • YouTube
    © 2025 Andrew Reid / EOSHD

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.