For events and fast-unfolding coverage I currently use the trusty Sigma 18-35 f/1.8, and a Samyang (Rokinon) 85mm f/1.4 on a GH4 with Speedbooster (S version, similar to Ultra).
That combo has served me well, and I'm happy with just about every aspect of using them, except - lens changes is now driving me crazy. It's an inconvenience at best, and at worst means either making creative compromises or missing vital shots.
I'm looking for a general (widish to portrait or even tele) zoom to take their place. I'm upgrading to the GH5S at some point soon, too.
I have the following requirements:
Manual focus (no focus-by-wire)
Constant aperture
Minimum f/2.8 (f/2 or more even better)
Weight, size, not really an issue (within reason!)
Zoom range replicating as much of my current available field of view as possible
Apologies in advance if the following contains mathematical or conceptual errors!
For reference, my current set-up covers:
18mm - 35mm on the Sigma w/SB, so that's ≡ 29mm - 56mm (FF),
and 85mm on the Samyang w/SB ≡ 136mm
So, here's some lenses that' I've considered so far:
Olympus ZUIKO 14-35mm f/2.0 w/ 4/3 adaptor ≡ 28 - 70
This is an out-of-production FOUR THIRDS lens that I got interested in. It's the only viable f/2 zoom I could find. Bit of a scary purchase though, as it is both expensive, and out of production (there are a few around though - B&H lists it as new!)
Sigma 18-35 f1.8 w/ Active adaptor ≡ 35 - 70
Then I had the inspired idea of taking my Sigma off of the Speedbooster and sticking it on a regular active EF-MFT adaptor. That would give me extra reach at the cost of some light sensitivity (not such an issue moving to the GH5S), and save me a ton of cash compared to buying a new lens.
Samsung16-50mm f/2 -f/2.8 S w/ (sadly non-existent) adaptor ≡ 32 - 100
This breaks my 'constant aperture' rule, but I'd be willing to make an exception as it essentially adds in a bonus f/2 where ordinarily there would only be f/2.8 through the range. Despite being theoretically possible, I don't think there are any Samsung --> MFT adaptors out there ?.
Olympus M.ZUIKO PRO 12–40mm f/2.8 (native) ≡ 24 - 80
On to the more obvious choices. Nothing wrong with this lens, of course. Only thing holding me back is the f/2.8. I'm not one of those people that plasters everything with shallow DoF shots, but I like to have (and have become used to having) the option when it enhances the production.
Canon EF 24-70mm f/2.8L II w/ SB ≡ 38 - 112
I think this is currently my favourite option, because I like the zoom range, though obviously the f/2.8 limitation is irksome.
So, any thoughts? Any lenses I've missed out? Am I going about this all wrong? Does one of the above stand out as a winner?