Jump to content

Lumix SHX1 FF cinema camera


kye
 Share

Recommended Posts

OK, I quite like it but on the fence…

Smaller/faster/lighter is my mantra, but at the same time, real world use ability.

I have been contemplating all year long flipping one of my S1Rii bodies for an S1ii to pair with and go back to a dedicated stills unit plus a dedicated video unit rather than two hybrid units as my main workhorses (a pair of S5ii’s for static duty) because the S1Rii DOES still overheat in some of my use case and environments and I cannot rely on it at such times.

The S1ii is/was currently my best option to fix that if remaining with Lumix, but the SHX1 is actually more interesting…

I don’t like the price. I think it’s about 1k more than it should be IMO, but not a deal-breaker.

I would have preferred an internal ND but not at the expense of omitting IBIS (Sigma FP2 I am looking at you) which would have been a dealbreaker…and the IBIS looks to be the best yet and that gets a big thumbs up from me.

Other than the side handle, I wouldn’t rig it out and would have preferred a bigger screen but hey ho, the one it comes with might not be ZR level, but at least it tilts and stays in line with the body/lens which if anything, is even more important to me.

OLPF. Yay. I haven’t been experiencing any issues with moire etc from the S1Rii or S5ii but the S1H probably still has/had the best image SOOC for me and that may have been due to the OLPF…

Plus the sensor has been ‘tweaked’ they say so isn’t exactly the same as the S1ii but it remains to be seen what the actual production model codecs are as there’s a few anomalies in the current listed spec. Probably just pre-production firmware…

A ‘lightweight’ version of this, I’d want to run either Lumix’s own 24-60 or Sigma’s 28-70 and a ‘heavyweight’ would be Sigma’s 28-105 but therein lies a compromise…

And then there is the talk of an S9ii…

A slightly more rugged build and the screen mech from the S1ii/S1Rii and it’s a done deal for me and I’d rather go with that far more compact set up.

I’ve got until the late Spring to decide so staying perched on my fence until then.

Overall though, I think it’s a good launch. Not perfect (nothing ever is), but very good.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

EOSHD Pro Color 5 for Sony cameras EOSHD Z LOG for Nikon CamerasEOSHD C-LOG and Film Profiles for All Canon DSLRs
8 hours ago, MrSMW said:

OK, I quite like it but on the fence…

Smaller/faster/lighter is my mantra, but at the same time, real world use ability.

I have been contemplating all year long flipping one of my S1Rii bodies for an S1ii to pair with and go back to a dedicated stills unit plus a dedicated video unit rather than two hybrid units as my main workhorses (a pair of S5ii’s for static duty) because the S1Rii DOES still overheat in some of my use case and environments and I cannot rely on it at such times.

The S1ii is/was currently my best option to fix that if remaining with Lumix, but the SHX1 is actually more interesting…

I don’t like the price. I think it’s about 1k more than it should be IMO, but not a deal-breaker.

I would have preferred an internal ND but not at the expense of omitting IBIS (Sigma FP2 I am looking at you) which would have been a dealbreaker…and the IBIS looks to be the best yet and that gets a big thumbs up from me.

Other than the side handle, I wouldn’t rig it out and would have preferred a bigger screen but hey ho, the one it comes with might not be ZR level, but at least it tilts and stays in line with the body/lens which if anything, is even more important to me.

OLPF. Yay. I haven’t been experiencing any issues with moire etc from the S1Rii or S5ii but the S1H probably still has/had the best image SOOC for me and that may have been due to the OLPF…

Plus the sensor has been ‘tweaked’ they say so isn’t exactly the same as the S1ii but it remains to be seen what the actual production model codecs are as there’s a few anomalies in the current listed spec. Probably just pre-production firmware…

A ‘lightweight’ version of this, I’d want to run either Lumix’s own 24-60 or Sigma’s 28-70 and a ‘heavyweight’ would be Sigma’s 28-105 but therein lies a compromise…

And then there is the talk of an S9ii…

A slightly more rugged build and the screen mech from the S1ii/S1Rii and it’s a done deal for me and I’d rather go with that far more compact set up.

I’ve got until the late Spring to decide so staying perched on my fence until then.

Overall though, I think it’s a good launch. Not perfect (nothing ever is), but very good.

I'm on the same fence. I think the grip and top handle should have been included at the base, body-only price and it would have been a slam dunk for me. This is exactly the camera I wanted 18 months ago when I ordered the Pyxis 12K. Given a flat choice, I'd choose this for my needs every time.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There’s a lot of chat re. this and the Pyxis and Black Magic and I’d go for this also being 100% as things stand within the L Mount system and for me it will come down to one single thing really and that is by April 2027 latest, will an S9ii be available (and to my spec) because if not, I’m either going partially in to Sony for stills and sticking with L Mount for video, or going all in on a Nikon/Sony set up and leaving L Mount for good.

I’m 99% certain I am going Sony for stills as the combo of body & lenses just cannot be matched within L Mount, but whether I could justify this SHX1 financially also, is another question, but probably not.

It’s lenses. It’s always bloody lenses. If L Mount would just have the lenses I need and there are 4 within E Mount that just do not exist with L 😏

So that’s another potential actually because if from within L they can release at least 1 or 2 within the next 5 months…

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Administrators

That's how I feel about it too, it's a GREAT box camera but I think cinema cameras bit the bullet for me 10 years ago, I don't want a sensor in a box, I don't see the point of having such efficient modern sensor and processor but a massive v-lock battery on the back, and buttons in silly places scattered down the side where you need 3 hands to reach them, it's the sort of thing you would use with a crew like an Alexa on a big heavy tripod rig, and wonder why they bothered to make it so small and light if that's the way it gets treated under normal conditions... Just not my bag, it doesn't make sense for me.

Give me an S1H II already and make it quick Panasonic.

Something like a Canon XC10 form factor for that would be great, give the DSLR form factor a break it is getting really tired. At least go for the rangefinder shape if you do an S1H II so the FX3 gets some much needed competition!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I used a C100 last weekend.

Forgot how nice it was to film with.

Imagine if Panasonic had gone that route, including internal ND.

I know there were a lot of people saying they wanted a box style camera from them, but I'm tired of rigging things up. Give me a tool that needs minimal add ons and lets rip!

I'm glad they made something, it just isn't for me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Where I live, this comes in close to 2,000 dollars (Cad) higher than an Fx5 and about 4-5,000 dollars higher than a S1ii... Almost 6k more than a zR. 

Much more than a pyxis, too.

As someone with two S1H bodies and an S1 as primary cameras, all I've wanted is for the S1ii / zR sensor to find its way into an S1H body with maybe a better rigging option for xlr via top handle, an olpf with better h265 handling, integrating the incremental quality of life upgrades we've seen on the way with newer panasonic releases - 4 channel audio, 32 bit, punch in while recording to check focus, false color. 

This is a confusing camera. It's built for rigging and it basically requires an external monitor to function properly with manual lenses, but according to reviews panasonic hasn't fixed HDMI or SDI latency - so that's already a poor start. And while it builds up nicely, there's no real way to build it down - an fx5 will always edge this out as a crash cam or discreet body. The menu design also seems poor,  given that your navigating a hybrid menu without properly placed dials. You have to disable phantom power in menu and not via a switch?  Yikes! 

As far as I can see, it has only one standout feature and that's the inclusion of excellent ibis in this form factor. This is welcome... Ibis is one of the main reasons I still shoot panasonic. 

I think this camera will be used for a lot of good work for a long time, but only by a self selected and frankly masochistic group of panasonic loyalists who are willing to overpay and put up with bizarre quirks. Everyone else will default to the fx5, provided it proves reliable enough, and five years from now that camera will sell close to its initial price while these things will have a 75 percent discount.

I've been playing recently with my Gh5 and just remaining blown away at how good it is, how functional and ergonomical and fully featured. For the time, there was nothing that came close to it, and it kept meaningfully improving with firmware. These days, on the other hand, panasonic has no edge and is under resourced. It's been a while since they've had an obvious winner, and at this rate they may never again. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This all depends, really, on what your workflow is and what you're trying to shoot.

If you're shooting handheld run-n-gun as a single operator, with sound directly into the camera and no director's screen, a DSLR-style body is well-optimized for that.  If you're on set and you need to add a timecode box, a transmitter, and a follow focus, you end up putting the DSLR into a cage and juryrigging a bigger battery onto it so that you can power all of your accessories at once instead of monitoring multiple different batteries.  At this point, the DSLR starts to look ridiculous.  You probably also put on a bigger screen to make it reasonable to judge focus without being able to hold the camera right up to your face.  Now you might notice that pulling focus is harder because the HDMI you plugged it into has 4-6 frames of latency.  Your timecode box, btw, is plugged into your audio jack now and trying to listen to playback results in hearing a series of clicks on at least one of the tracks.

At this point, a bigger camera that has different I/O starts to make sense.  The timecode box plugs into a dedicated timecode port.  The camera has at least one SDI port so you can connect a monitor with less latency.  It comes with a V-mount built right in.  It probably even has XLR ports to plug in a decent shotgun mic.  I've had shots saved by my camera's shotgun mic when the audio engineer was picking up something weird/wind noise/etc. 

And in this case, if you don't like the box, Panasonic would probably be glad to just sell you an S1 II which is very not-boxy.  They'd probably also point out that you can use the S1 II as a b cam for a rented SHX1 if you only occasionally go on a set where the camera gets rigged up.

This is also why it's weird to me that Panasonic chose IBIS over built-in ND.  This style of boxy camera is less suited to running around shooting handheld.  It's likely one of the reasons that Canon went with built-in ND on the C70 and C80 instead of putting in IBIS.  Their sales person would probably tell you that if you want IBIS, you should just use an R6 III or similar, which is already well-designed for handheld use.

That said, not all boxy cameras aren't incompatible with being small/portable for run and gun - my OG Komodo is set up really well for it in a hybrid way right now.  I have it set up with a V mount adapter that hard connects to one of the BP-U slots.  I have a Pyro 5 plugged into that which gives monitoring and decent transmission.  When I need TC, I can actually stick it to the back of the V mount plate.  RVLVR released an update to the Clutch handle a while ago which gives it control on the Komodo - so I have a nice comfy wooden handle that has run-stop as well as aperture control and focus magnify right next to the record button.  No need to take my hand from the handle for most things that I need to do while shooting.  If I'm using EF lenses, I can also use the Canon inline vND adapter so I basically have built-in ND as well.  If I really need/want to stabilize in post, the Komodo also records gyro data so I can go into Gyroflow or similar (but I usually don't because their plugin for Resolve was sucky/annoying last time I tried it, wonder if it got better?).

Anyway.  Right tool for the right job.  It's great that Panasonic are giving this option to people that like their cameras, but don't want something that looks like a DSLR.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, eatstoomuchjam said:

The timecode box plugs into a dedicated timecode port

I mean timecode is essential I/O for a lot of my work - but it's also something that the S1H had a solution for. The Atomos / Bluetooth timecode solution of this S1II is one of its major deficiencies that you can't really put onto a sound person to troubleshoot.

It does seem like the Panasonic product line could use a middle ground - something between a full on rig-focused 'cinema camera' and a stills-style hybrid. Like gimme an S1ii with OLPF and timecode, or introduce a serious timecode solution for the S1ii...

I wonder if there is anything else coming down the line.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • EOSHD Pro Color 5 for All Sony cameras
    EOSHD C-LOG and Film Profiles for All Canon DSLRs
    EOSHD Dynamic Range Enhancer for H.264/H.265
×
×
  • Create New...