Jump to content

MrSMW

Members
  • Posts

    4,353
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by MrSMW

  1. I don't know how others think of these things but being conspicuous (or not) is more to me about how you behave and occupy a space rather than the tools that you use. For the work I do, it's more about the size and even more, the weight, to me. There's not much difference between a 1kg set up compared with a 1.5kg set up in the hand and I've worked with units up to around 2.5-3kg and in hand, all day long, it's too much. 2kg is kind of doable but my self-imposed limit these days is really a max of 1.5kg. And it's not just size and weight, but ergonomics and balance and something slightly larger, but still lightweight and ergonomically good, is going to better than something smaller that weighs the same but isn't ergonomically great. So yes, I could personally see myself using something like the SHX1 with a relatively compact lens and small shotgun mic for run & gun work, especially so if I am already invested in the system with an S1Rii on my other hip for stills and a pair of S5ii's for static work. On another note, I like the image coming out of it. I prefer the S1Rii actually for it's quality of video over the S1ii, but the subtle tweak that Panasonic have done with this sensor combined with the OLPF has made a difference and in the right hands, it shows. I think it's a good release. A bit over-priced and I'm not decided whether it's something I'll take up or not and would rather have seen something in-line with the Nikon ZR/Sony FX style of body. It will be interesting to see where it goes with firmware in the future and if they can get around the lack of internal Braw. The fact it has to be recorded to SSD makes it external in most rational people's opinion! Is trying to, or simply does? Either by sheer coincidence or design, I think it does appeal to various types of potential user...
  2. I think we could go further and also say us 'run & gun' event type shooters would mostly value IBIS over internal ND whereas more static types that rig stuff out, don't necessarily need internal ND, but IBIS is useless to them. Anyone that shoots 8-12 hours handheld, often for multiple days in a row values not just size & weight, but how fast we can go from seeing something to shooting it which is often under a second. On that basis, we do tend to have our kit set up more or less like 'point & shoot' cameras and that's where custom modes come in. C1 outdoor C2 indoor C3 low-light I do think the SHX1 would make a good 'run & gun' camera as long as it's kept simple, ie, probably an AF zoom lens, compact shotgun mic and good to go!
  3. I think there are 3 levels of rigging: 1. Those of us that don’t or at a bare minimum and a second monitor for instance is a no. We’d also rather not shoot external SSD. This is why the Sigma FP2 disappointed me so much, - it was just one single feature away from being perfect, - no IBIS. 2. Those that need to rig stuff out and certain types of job/work need more than a bare bones mirrorless S9 and that’s fair enough. 3. Those that rig stuff out and make YouTube videos about it but never actually shoot anything. Their favourite movie is Transformers and they worship Michael Bay as their god. The SHX1 looks more comfortable to hold/use than a typical DSLR style body and other than custom mode buttons, I don’t tend to need to do anything else on the fly. Compact shotgun mic would be my only accessory with this. My ONLY issue is the Lumix 24-60 or Sigma 28-70 are a very decent size & weight but don’t have the reach I’d like, whereas the Sigma 28-105 does, but is bordering on chonk… Meanwhile, in E Mount we have the Tamron 35-100 which pretty much has the range of the Sigma 28-105 but is closer to the Sigma 28-70 in size & weight. Then we have the ridiculously tiny but capable Sigma 50-120 f2.8…. OK, it’s APSC so a 75-180 in FF equivalency and for those of us more than happy to shoot S35, an insanely compact featherweight option…but not available in L Mount…which is an utterly STOOPID decision by Sigma because on the SHX1 or any other FF Lumix, Sigma or even Leica, it would be bloody brilliant. So I am especially annoyed at Sigma right now, - FP2 no IBIS and then launched this 50-120…but you can’t use it with their own bodies 🤬🤬
  4. There’s a lot of chat re. this and the Pyxis and Black Magic and I’d go for this also being 100% as things stand within the L Mount system and for me it will come down to one single thing really and that is by April 2027 latest, will an S9ii be available (and to my spec) because if not, I’m either going partially in to Sony for stills and sticking with L Mount for video, or going all in on a Nikon/Sony set up and leaving L Mount for good. I’m 99% certain I am going Sony for stills as the combo of body & lenses just cannot be matched within L Mount, but whether I could justify this SHX1 financially also, is another question, but probably not. It’s lenses. It’s always bloody lenses. If L Mount would just have the lenses I need and there are 4 within E Mount that just do not exist with L 😏 So that’s another potential actually because if from within L they can release at least 1 or 2 within the next 5 months…
  5. OK, I quite like it but on the fence… Smaller/faster/lighter is my mantra, but at the same time, real world use ability. I have been contemplating all year long flipping one of my S1Rii bodies for an S1ii to pair with and go back to a dedicated stills unit plus a dedicated video unit rather than two hybrid units as my main workhorses (a pair of S5ii’s for static duty) because the S1Rii DOES still overheat in some of my use case and environments and I cannot rely on it at such times. The S1ii is/was currently my best option to fix that if remaining with Lumix, but the SHX1 is actually more interesting… I don’t like the price. I think it’s about 1k more than it should be IMO, but not a deal-breaker. I would have preferred an internal ND but not at the expense of omitting IBIS (Sigma FP2 I am looking at you) which would have been a dealbreaker…and the IBIS looks to be the best yet and that gets a big thumbs up from me. Other than the side handle, I wouldn’t rig it out and would have preferred a bigger screen but hey ho, the one it comes with might not be ZR level, but at least it tilts and stays in line with the body/lens which if anything, is even more important to me. OLPF. Yay. I haven’t been experiencing any issues with moire etc from the S1Rii or S5ii but the S1H probably still has/had the best image SOOC for me and that may have been due to the OLPF… Plus the sensor has been ‘tweaked’ they say so isn’t exactly the same as the S1ii but it remains to be seen what the actual production model codecs are as there’s a few anomalies in the current listed spec. Probably just pre-production firmware… A ‘lightweight’ version of this, I’d want to run either Lumix’s own 24-60 or Sigma’s 28-70 and a ‘heavyweight’ would be Sigma’s 28-105 but therein lies a compromise… And then there is the talk of an S9ii… A slightly more rugged build and the screen mech from the S1ii/S1Rii and it’s a done deal for me and I’d rather go with that far more compact set up. I’ve got until the late Spring to decide so staying perched on my fence until then. Overall though, I think it’s a good launch. Not perfect (nothing ever is), but very good.
  6. Precisely what I was looking for… I’m on the verge of a Nikon/Sony flip… It’s not so much the bodies, but I do prefer the ZR/FX style over the DSLR Lumix lot, but more the glass where there are still glaring holes. The reality is the opposition offer the better bodies and better lenses for my needs/wants and the insides are more or less comparable so it seems like a no-brainer to me. I will go and trawl through a few YouTube reviews now but suspect this new alphabet Lumix won’t be for me…
  7. I don’t mean easy easy but if you managed the S9, the S5ii should be easy-er?
  8. Internal raw on the S9 would be at least something I’d have a play with and I guess the S5ii would be as ‘easy’ to crack?
  9. S9 specifically, to what purpose? Other than Flappy Birds, obvs, but what does it otherwise mean? Serious Q!
  10. Sadly, it’s just part of the world that we now live in. It peaked for me around 1986/87, though at the time as a teen, I did not realise or appreciate it. I rank my decades as: 1980’s, 1970’s, 1990’s, 2000’s, 2010’s with the 2020’s firmly in last place… I don’t think the world/society is fucked as such, just that it is in decline and the more it is (IMO), the less I take part in it and do my own thing(s) instead. Unfortunately, the human race & society cannot be hacked…
  11. Maybe someone can reduce the file sizes of Red Raw on the ZR to around 20-25% of the size and then after that, work on adding IBIS to the FP2 so that it can be purchased by the other 95% of potential purchasers.
  12. I previously said that the new Sigma FP 2 fell short for me in a single area, the lack of IBIS. But I was wrong. It also lacks Commando that I used to have on the Commodore 64. #thetightarsetwats
  13. Which I guess means cannot bake a LUT into it then which is another strike for me. I’d rather they went the Panasonic path so it was more compatible with my LUMIX cameras and workflow, but hey ho.
  14. Yes, the ZR is the new benchmark in a number of ways and for me is probably the pick of the bunch of these new ‘cine’ style bodies including: S9, ZV-E1, R6V and now FP2. I love the size and build of the FP and the new rear LCD, but that lack of IBIS, aaaaaaargh! S9 has the best video spec for me (the ZR beats it sure with it’s Red Raw but for the massive amount of storage it gobbles) but the ZR counters with a very nice body and rear LCD….except I would rather it was fully articulated (first choice) or at least tilted like the FP (second choice) but really don’t like the flip out to the side. I don’t care for that side mounted EVF though. Ugly as fuck and all the FP would need for me is a base plate and grip and I’d be off with it. But that’s if it had IBIS, which it doesn’t so back on the fence waiting to see what LUMIX do. FP2 was/is one single element away from being perfect for me. ZR is two elements. ZV-E1 two elements (rear LCD and something else I forget). S9 two elements (rear LCD and overall build). Someone will hopefully get it right soon…
  15. Because I am a contrary bastard? 🤷‍♂️ But feet back on the ground, you are correct and that lack of IBIS and L Mount having precisely zero wide-medium zooms with OIS, is a deal-breaker. I looked up the e-stab and the gyro data option and neither interest me. I was considering sticking one on a monopod which I use increasingly and will be picking one up with a clutch for next year and will still be getting one of the latter, but having calmed down now and recognised that Sigma have indeed failed me in the camera department for the third time with their FP line, yeah but no. Love the concept, size, build, brand and now rear tilt LCD, but the reality is that despite hating the spasticky rear dial, buttons and general build of the S9, the LUMIX is a better camera for my needs. Really what I am looking for would be the spec of the S1ii or preferably the S1Rii in a cine style body. Love their glass and I am all in on that, but another body fail for me. At least this time it was by only one single element instead of several, but the lack of IBIS kills it for me.
  16. The ONLY thing 'missing' for me is IBIS but curious about how this gyro data will work. Not pulling the trigger just yet but waiting to see what LUMIX do themselves, rumoured to be 'something similar' next month. But so far, so good for the FP2, - it could become my workhorse in 2027...
  17. I prefer dogs and land mines.
  18. Well nothing was announced this week but it’s looking most likely like a Sigma FP2. Meanwhile LUMIX is supposed to be revealing at least 2 new bodies in November to mark their 25th birthday or something… Please let this not be some letdown like a security camera or some other crap but something ‘we’ might be interested in… Too soon for a GH8 so maybe some small compact L10-like MILC? Maybe the long overdue S1H2, or some ‘cine’ version of the S1ii?
  19. MrSMW

    Log is Boring

    I also get where you are coming from and that is why I bake the LUT into my footage. I set up all my cameras with 3 basic profiles based on ISO and WB for outdoor, indoor and low-lowlight scenarios. I say LUT, but there are actually 2x LUTS stacked; the conversion LUT and then my own custom ‘Look LUT’ which can be dialled in anywhere between 10-100%. It gets the look I want SOOC and it’s as unique to me as these things can be, is easy in the workflow and allows me to concentrate more on the interesting side of editing a film rather than the boring to me, more logistical grading. Only really works if no one else has a say in the end result and I’m fortunate that I’m my work, the grade is 100% my call.
  20. That is exactly it; so many of us wanted the FP and would have bought or kept the FP if only it had been a little more useable and that is going to be one of the, if not the biggest key(s) to it’s success. Yes some folks want to rig stuff out but the kind of people that are looking at FP’s tend to be single camera purists not film crews making big productions. Some folks made and continue to make the OG FP work, but the majority of us voted with our wallets. I really hope Sigma get this right this time, not for the masses, but for their market. It won’t and can’t have all things, but I hope it has the key ones and that for me is IBIS & tilt. For me, they could keep everything else the same, but those 2 things are the deal sealers for me.
  21. Could do as Panasonic are not Sigma’s master…but I don’t think it will have all the features of an S1ii, but no IBIS would probably be a deal-breaker for me as it would need to have a superb level of digital stabilisation for my needs. I don’t know about others, but I’m not one for rigging stuff out and so few OIS L Mount lenses.
  22. An FP with the S1ii sensor, tilt screen and IBIS for me would be done deal. Before the S1ii/S1Rii came out in basically a modified S5ii chassis…which I don’t mind, I had hoped and would have preferred the cine style body of the FX3. I tested and loved the concept of the FP-L but just too many compromises. I got why Sigma didn’t make a mainstream camera but at the same time, you have to have certain stuff or it will hurt sales. As far as I am aware, the FP has never been anything but a low selling cult camera. I don’t think a new model would change that scenario that much but surely at least addressing a couple of key areas is going to help in that regard. If this new camera is an FP2 and if it has certain features, I don’t think it would be enough for anyone to be chucking away whole systems to go over to, but for those maybe already in L Mount or for folks that only need one camera, it could be viable. It has to be a bit more than an S9 though…
  23. Quite possibly, ie, an 'FX30 competitor' except full-frame with the FX3 'competitor' next year as the 'S1H2'. I'm struggling to see where anything from LUMIX would fit in as the S5ii, S1ii and S9 already exist and it's too soon to replace even the oldest of these plus it would be direct competition and hurt sales of these existing models surely? UNLESS it's a stills orientated camera, but even then... So I am sticking with Sigma, DJI, Black Magic as the most likely candidates with the former two being the strongest contenders IMO. I wouldn't expect Leica to be popping out a dedicated 'cine' camera and this thing is most likely to be that by the sounds of it, or at least heavily orientated as with the Nikon ZR...and they definitely do not need a competitor from within their own ranks for their M, SL and Q cameras. But what do I know and all pure speculation!
  24. I meant to also say not as such, but I am (always) looking at ways to introduce character into my files over adding anything in post. I am currently in the process of considering a new photo camera and in doing so have mused over so many options and one of the options is going low megapixel. When I say low, I mean around 12mp and still FF, so not quite loooooow quality. In fact not ‘low’ quality at all, but more ‘character’ and by character, I’ve been thinking about the most challenging year in my career which was when I spent most of an entire season shooting weddings with a single OG Fuji X100 with it’s fixed lens, single card slot and 12mp sensor. That thing was slow as fuck compared with what came later, never mind more current models, but the files… They were the closest SOOC to analogue I have ever come across. A few years later, I bought a used one to check that I had not imagined it and yup, that magic was still there. But could I go back? To that specific camera? Hell no, but I would recommend it to anyone who likes the idea of shooting film who wanted to stay digital. I have thought about getting another and whipping it out to do some ‘artistic’ stuff but as a hybrid shooter spinning enough plates already, decided against and instead looking at other options to achieve ‘character’ the principal one being glass. The only issue with that really is character mostly comes with older glass and that doesn’t tend to autofocus or does so very badly adapted with one of several manual to autofocus adapters…so that’s not working for me… The best I have come up with so far then is the Sony ZVE-1 (12mp and fantastic AF) with the Thypoch 24-50mm f2.8 (internal zoom!) that they say has rendering between a modern clinical lens and a cine lens and has a coating that seems to lower contrast and invite flaring. It could be the 2026 version of the 2011 Fuji X100 that would not be utter madness to shoot as a one & done… And it does video!
  25. I’m fortunate that I am all in with L Mount but currently 1 camera body short… One of my S9 ‘B’ cams had an issue mid season and I worked around it with my EDC L10 for a few jobs and despite the quality of the output (it is the GH7 sensor after all!) it’s not suited for my needs. That second S9 was going to cost more to fix than another used one, so I’ve re-purposed it as a photo camera for my daughter. So a camera body short, season over, 6 months to the next one, just sold the L10, the gimbal and 3 lenses and twiddling my thumbs… My ideal is a ZR/FX3 body with the ZR screen on the fully articulated mech of the S1Rii and ideally the sensor from the S1Rii and cheaper than the FX5. Not asking for much then…😂 But seriously, the timing of this could be good for me as though I am considering a different photo camera, I would ideally keep it all in the same system for lenses and batteries and, well everything really. I need either: 4 video units and 1 photo or 3 video units and 2 hybrid (as I currently have less 1 defunct video unit) So I am interested in either a more photo-orientated camera but in a more rangefinderesque body style à la ZR/FX3/FP, or a hybrid in this body style. I don’t much care about the branding so it could be LUMIX, Sigma or DJI, or even Black Magic for photo, but ideally LUMIX for video as baking in my LUT is part of my workflow. I don’t see BM making a stills-orientated camera and I’m not sure LUMIX are going to pop out an FX3 style body just yet so most likely a new Sigma or DJI and of the two, maybe DJI most likely as it has been rumoured for a while? It will be interesting at the very least to see if it meets my needs, but if not, I’ve already got my options planned… I’m going to guess in most likely order: 1. DJI 2. Sigma 3. LUMIX 4. Black Magic 5. Leica
×
×
  • Create New...