Jump to content

Andrew - EOSHD

Administrators
  • Posts

    15,780
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Andrew - EOSHD

  1. if you have 10bit per channel to convert to 8bit per channel, noise dithering is not the best algorithm, diffusion dithering is better the typical algorithm is Floyd–Steinberg - look at the difference with the noise or "random" algorithm it is day and night :  http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dither

    Michelangelo%27s_David_-_ruis.png vs Michelangelo%27s_David_-_Floyd-Steinberg

     

    Good luck doing that in your NLE :)

     

    If there is a way, do correct me if I'm wrong :)



  2. The EOSHD Panasonic GH4 Shooter’s Guide is now available

    8bit DSLR codecs get quite a lot of bashing for banding, and it is something we're well used too... A sky or a wall taking up half the shot with only 4 or 5 shades where there should be a silky smooth gradient with thousands of tiny steps in-between darker and slightly lighter areas of the image.

    However one of the first things I noticed with the Panasonic GH4 was that banding was greatly reduced and it looked like my 10bit Blackmagic footage, even though it was still an 8bit codec (internally with 4K). Why such a turn-around for an 8bit codec? It turns out the 4K mode on the GH4 holds the key to hiding this banding... yet it is something we can apply to all DSLRS...

    Here's how...

     

    Read the full article here
  3. Well that is exactly what I am saying about the noise and compression.

     

    Compression hurts the noise-dither, making banding more apparent.

     

    And buy the way, I shrunk your banding image...

     

    16bit.jpg

     

    Guess what, the bands are thinner on the shrunk version... Whudda thought!?

     

    Downsampling 4K to 2K clearly has makes gradation finer...

     

    And if everyone agrees on the 4 8bit numbers = 1 10bit number, then surely when we take dithering, finer gradients and grading a ProRes file into consideration, you are going to see less banding aren't you?

     

    For those with 10bit LCDs can you download this 10bit TIFF from a 16Bit Photoshop gradient and tell us if you see the banding. I do on my iMac display. http://www.eoshd.com/uploads/16bit.tif

  4. 8bit has easily enough to give you a sky with more than 4 bands gradient. It has enough for 256 shades in that sky.

     

    The banding in Ebrahim's sample was caused by compression in-camera and then compression of luma in post, with a high contrast. I can break 10bit footage in the same way if I ramp contrast all the way up. Just tried it.

     

    I just did a quick test, nothing special... But clearly the gradient is handled just fine by 8bit HDMI and 8bit 4K. The 8bit 1080p has banding caused by compression. The compression removes the dithering between shades.

     

    Peep carefully.... :)

     

    gh4-hdmi-banding-comparison.jpg

     

    In conclusion...You only REALLY need 10bit if you want to grade heavily. You shouldn't normally notice the difference between 10bit and 8bit footage. Bodes well for the A7S doesn't it?

  5. I also don't see banding in the Andrew's photo above. So what do you think Andrew? His tests above seem to prove 4K 8 bit has the same amount of banding when downscaled to 2K.

     

    I already told you several times what I think...

     

    Compression is a factor, as is exposure.

     

    I also said countless times before... 10bit luma is is not the same as having 10bit colour.

     

    I also told you that David Newman of CineForm / GoPro backs up the 8bit 4K -> 10bit 1080p argument as does Thomas Worth of Rarevision. If you can't listen to the experts, I as a non-colour science engineer will have no chance in putting you straight!!

  6. It looks like mega extreme push or pull, no wonder it is shot to pieces.

     

    Try instead shooting a detailed surface which is unevenly lit, say with a light source at one edge of it, shoot it in 4K then don't touch the image, just convert it to 1080p 10bit ProRes. Only after that, see how it grades compared to the 8bit 1080p files direct from the GH4.

  7. It isn't an image quality thing...

     

    The different 1080p modes vary in other ways.

     

    ALL-I for instance is easier on your computer to edit. The complex encoding for IPB is not there, just each individual frame 'as-is' one after the other like a sequence of JPEGs.

     

    The bitrate of 200Mbit/s is higher in ALL-I just to maintain image quality, not to improve it from 100Mbit/s in IPB mode.

     

    Because the efficiency of an ALL-I codec is lower, the data rate needs to increase.

     

    So it is a common user misconception that image quality and bitrate have a direct correlation!

     

    Shoot 1080p ALL-I if you need easier to edit files.

     

    Shoot 1080p IPB if you need smaller file sizes and best quality compression.

     

    Shoot 4K and upgrade your laptop if you want to get a clue ;)

  8. As long as it takes to fix.

     

    It isn't in my hands so I'm not really the one to ask.

     

    Let's move along please, as people will use this topic to dig for info and I don't think that's fair on me.

  9. Did any one take a picture of a sky in 4k, and scaled it down to 1080p, and saw if it reduced banding and added more gradient?

     

    4x smaller bands = finer gradient.

     

    Simple enough yeah?

  10. Image quality looks identical to the Sony RX10 but the higher bitrate should really help with the heavy breakup and mud I experienced with that camera. Glad to see the back of AVCHD as well.

     

    Curious to see if moire is dealt with better this time too.

     

    Great compact camera... Perhaps the best.

     

    Not a DSLR / mirrorless beater due to sensor size and no interchangeable lenses but for what it is, it seems very good... love the pop up EVF!

     

    Might be good on drones too.

×
×
  • Create New...