MrSMW Posted 10 hours ago Share Posted 10 hours ago OK, I quite like it but on the fence… Smaller/faster/lighter is my mantra, but at the same time, real world use ability. I have been contemplating all year long flipping one of my S1Rii bodies for an S1ii to pair with and go back to a dedicated stills unit plus a dedicated video unit rather than two hybrid units as my main workhorses (a pair of S5ii’s for static duty) because the S1Rii DOES still overheat in some of my use case and environments and I cannot rely on it at such times. The S1ii is/was currently my best option to fix that if remaining with Lumix, but the SHX1 is actually more interesting… I don’t like the price. I think it’s about 1k more than it should be IMO, but not a deal-breaker. I would have preferred an internal ND but not at the expense of omitting IBIS (Sigma FP2 I am looking at you) which would have been a dealbreaker…and the IBIS looks to be the best yet and that gets a big thumbs up from me. Other than the side handle, I wouldn’t rig it out and would have preferred a bigger screen but hey ho, the one it comes with might not be ZR level, but at least it tilts and stays in line with the body/lens which if anything, is even more important to me. OLPF. Yay. I haven’t been experiencing any issues with moire etc from the S1Rii or S5ii but the S1H probably still has/had the best image SOOC for me and that may have been due to the OLPF… Plus the sensor has been ‘tweaked’ they say so isn’t exactly the same as the S1ii but it remains to be seen what the actual production model codecs are as there’s a few anomalies in the current listed spec. Probably just pre-production firmware… A ‘lightweight’ version of this, I’d want to run either Lumix’s own 24-60 or Sigma’s 28-70 and a ‘heavyweight’ would be Sigma’s 28-105 but therein lies a compromise… And then there is the talk of an S9ii… A slightly more rugged build and the screen mech from the S1ii/S1Rii and it’s a done deal for me and I’d rather go with that far more compact set up. I’ve got until the late Spring to decide so staying perched on my fence until then. Overall though, I think it’s a good launch. Not perfect (nothing ever is), but very good. MurtlandPhoto and eatstoomuchjam 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MurtlandPhoto Posted 2 hours ago Share Posted 2 hours ago 8 hours ago, MrSMW said: OK, I quite like it but on the fence… Smaller/faster/lighter is my mantra, but at the same time, real world use ability. I have been contemplating all year long flipping one of my S1Rii bodies for an S1ii to pair with and go back to a dedicated stills unit plus a dedicated video unit rather than two hybrid units as my main workhorses (a pair of S5ii’s for static duty) because the S1Rii DOES still overheat in some of my use case and environments and I cannot rely on it at such times. The S1ii is/was currently my best option to fix that if remaining with Lumix, but the SHX1 is actually more interesting… I don’t like the price. I think it’s about 1k more than it should be IMO, but not a deal-breaker. I would have preferred an internal ND but not at the expense of omitting IBIS (Sigma FP2 I am looking at you) which would have been a dealbreaker…and the IBIS looks to be the best yet and that gets a big thumbs up from me. Other than the side handle, I wouldn’t rig it out and would have preferred a bigger screen but hey ho, the one it comes with might not be ZR level, but at least it tilts and stays in line with the body/lens which if anything, is even more important to me. OLPF. Yay. I haven’t been experiencing any issues with moire etc from the S1Rii or S5ii but the S1H probably still has/had the best image SOOC for me and that may have been due to the OLPF… Plus the sensor has been ‘tweaked’ they say so isn’t exactly the same as the S1ii but it remains to be seen what the actual production model codecs are as there’s a few anomalies in the current listed spec. Probably just pre-production firmware… A ‘lightweight’ version of this, I’d want to run either Lumix’s own 24-60 or Sigma’s 28-70 and a ‘heavyweight’ would be Sigma’s 28-105 but therein lies a compromise… And then there is the talk of an S9ii… A slightly more rugged build and the screen mech from the S1ii/S1Rii and it’s a done deal for me and I’d rather go with that far more compact set up. I’ve got until the late Spring to decide so staying perched on my fence until then. Overall though, I think it’s a good launch. Not perfect (nothing ever is), but very good. I'm on the same fence. I think the grip and top handle should have been included at the base, body-only price and it would have been a slam dunk for me. This is exactly the camera I wanted 18 months ago when I ordered the Pyxis 12K. Given a flat choice, I'd choose this for my needs every time. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MrSMW Posted 1 hour ago Share Posted 1 hour ago There’s a lot of chat re. this and the Pyxis and Black Magic and I’d go for this also being 100% as things stand within the L Mount system and for me it will come down to one single thing really and that is by April 2027 latest, will an S9ii be available (and to my spec) because if not, I’m either going partially in to Sony for stills and sticking with L Mount for video, or going all in on a Nikon/Sony set up and leaving L Mount for good. I’m 99% certain I am going Sony for stills as the combo of body & lenses just cannot be matched within L Mount, but whether I could justify this SHX1 financially also, is another question, but probably not. It’s lenses. It’s always bloody lenses. If L Mount would just have the lenses I need and there are 4 within E Mount that just do not exist with L 😏 So that’s another potential actually because if from within L they can release at least 1 or 2 within the next 5 months… Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
newfoundmass Posted 1 hour ago Share Posted 1 hour ago Ed is really great and thoughtful. This really does seem like a good camera. I'm just not one of those box shape fans. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Administrators Andrew - EOSHD Posted 31 minutes ago Administrators Share Posted 31 minutes ago That's how I feel about it too, it's a GREAT box camera but I think cinema cameras bit the bullet for me 10 years ago, I don't want a sensor in a box, I don't see the point of having such efficient modern sensor and processor but a massive v-lock battery on the back, and buttons in silly places scattered down the side where you need 3 hands to reach them, it's the sort of thing you would use with a crew like an Alexa on a big heavy tripod rig, and wonder why they bothered to make it so small and light if that's the way it gets treated under normal conditions... Just not my bag, it doesn't make sense for me. Give me an S1H II already and make it quick Panasonic. Something like a Canon XC10 form factor for that would be great, give the DSLR form factor a break it is getting really tired. At least go for the rangefinder shape if you do an S1H II so the FX3 gets some much needed competition! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now