Administrators Andrew Reid Posted November 8, 2013 Author Administrators Share Posted November 8, 2013 Stephen, what makes the most difference in your experience - bit depth of colour sampling? Is 8bit unfairly maligned? Because the accepted wisdom in the DSLR community is currently that 8bit is the poster child for poor image quality. I've seen uncompressed 8bit 4:2:2 from the 5D Mark III's HDMI port and wasn't impressed. It looks like a similar result as you get with the internal compressed codec. But could we be pinning the blame on the wrong thing? The problem is, there's tons of data thrown away BEFORE the compression stage. Removing the compression makes no difference as by then the camera has already thrown away most of the sensor data. With raw it doesn't throw anything away after the feed leaves the sensor. The only loss is from the binning of resolution down from 22MP to 2MP on the sensor itself. My impression was that the uncompressed 5D Mark III HDMI output in the latest firmware was still debayered very poorly and heavily processed in-camera before it reached the HDMI port. They claim 4:2:2 colour sampling. I don't think it is debayered to 4:2:2 in camera. I think the signal is 4:2:2 but the data is the same old shit. The difference to the 8bit BBC broadcast stuff is that from sensor to media, the whole imaging pipeline is optimal. A bit more like the JPEG engine on a DSLR rather than video. Much less is thrown away. So what matters is more the entire pipeline - sensor sampling, A/D conversion, signal processing, debayering, encoding, compression quality and media performance. The problem with 8bit is with a heavy grade - no matter what the quality of the source - you are going to run out of gradation and tonal precision at some point, which risks introducing banding. Laptop on set.. I recommend Macbook Air from 2012 onwards. Fast USB 3.0 to transfer the card data quickly. CPU is quick enough to handle the debayer and playback smoothly. The software side is improving on a month to month basis. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.